parallax background

Tony's Pizza New York Style has proudly served the finest pizzas and Italian dishes for over 31 Years to the Crescent Beach and Saint Augustine area!

In this day and age, it is nearly impossible to find a truly authentic New York Style pizzeria with all the pretenders out there serving bland, frozen "pizza." However, fear not! Tony's Pizza only uses fresh, quality ingredients in our made-from-scratch meals.

Tony takes pride in offering only the best, truly authentic New York Style recipes at his restaurant. At Tony's Pizza, all of the sauces, dough, and meals are expertly crafted with care from scratch using old family recipes! Tony has followed a long tradition of serving only the best to his customers, family, and friends. This, paired with Tony's belief that the customer always comes first, brings the authentic New York Style Italian pizzeria and eatery to the First Coast!

Tony not only cooks with the freshest ingredients, but Tony's Pizza does not serve, and will never serve, yesterday's leftovers! Every hour, extra large pies for pizza by the slice are made fresh! As Tony always says, "Only the finest for my friends! Only the finest!"


Tony's Pizzas of the month

These are the local favorites for this month! Come in and try one, or call us at +1 (904) 471-9027 to order a pickup or delivery.